What happens when solenoid valve goes bad?

Common Symptoms of Solenoid Valve Failure

As a critical component in fluid control systems, a failing solenoid valve can manifest its problems in various ways. These early warning signs are crucial for swift troubleshooting and preventing more serious consequences. Here are the most common indicators:

Valve Won’t Open/Close

• Complete Inability to Shift: The most obvious sign. Causes could be electrical (burnt coil, broken wires), mechanical (stuck valve due to debris or corrosion), or a low-pressure differential for the valve to operate.
• Valve Sticking: Intermittent failure to open or close signals internal wear, contamination, or improper voltage. Burkert Type 6013 valves, with their unique rocker principle, are particularly robust against sticking due to particles or sediment in the fluid.

Leaks

• External Leaks: Check for loose fittings, damaged seals, or cracks in the valve body. Focus on points where sections join and where the solenoid assembly attaches.
• Internal Leaks: A valve leaking internally while closed may cause unexpected flow, system malfunctions, or pressure variations. This can be caused by worn seals or debris preventing full closure.

Slow Operation

• Sluggish Opening or Closing: This could indicate a weak coil, insufficient pressure, internal fouling of the valve, or incorrect sizing for the application’s flow rate.
• Delayed Response: A delay between energizing the solenoid and the valve shifting is often a sign of either mechanical resistance within the valve or a pressure-related issue.

Unusual Noises

• Water Hammer: Often confused with a valve fault, this loud banging sound is usually a system-wide pressure problem. However, a malfunctioning valve can sometimes exacerbate or trigger a water hammer.
• Buzzing: This may indicate coil problems or AC voltage issues. Note that some AC solenoids have a slight hum when energized, which is normal.
• Chattering: Rapid valve opening and closing often signifies incorrect voltage or an undersized valve for the application’s pressure.

Inconsistent Behavior

Intermittent or temperature-dependent problems are tricky to diagnose. Look for loose wiring, marginal coil performance, contamination buildup that varies with fluid temperature, or external factors in the installation environment.

Important: Always refer to the datasheet for your specific solenoid valve to interpret symptoms correctly and determine any unique failure modes.

Consequences of a Bad Solenoid Valve

The potential ramifications of a failing solenoid valve extend far beyond the valve itself. Depending on its role in your system, even a minor malfunction can ripple effect, leading to costly repairs, production losses, and even safety hazards.

Equipment Damage

• Beyond Pipes and Pumps: While damaged piping and pumps are a common outcome, failures can also impact specialized components like heat exchangers, filters, or sensitive instrumentation. Improper fluid flow can lead to overheating, inadequate filtration, or inaccurate readings that further propagate problems.
• The Risk of Contamination: Internal leaks within a valve can introduce unwanted fluids or particulates into sensitive parts of your system. This contamination can have long-term effects, such as accelerated component wear or product quality issues in manufacturing.

Process Disruptions

• Manufacturing Bottlenecks: Inconsistent batch quality, scrapped material, and unplanned downtime can result in a valve that cannot regulate flow reliably. Even brief disruptions create inefficiencies and potential knock-on effects on downstream processes.
• Critical Systems: Where precision and timing are paramount, like in dispensing chemicals or activating safety purge systems, a faulty valve can have more disastrous consequences. Failure can lead to improper mixing ratios, insufficient protection, or exceeding regulatory safety limits.

Safety Risks

• Machine Guarding Systems: Solenoid valves are often integral to stopping hazardous machinery quickly or isolating dangerous zones. A failed valve in this role directly impacts worker safety and puts your facility at risk of accidents.
• Pressure Relief and Venting: Proper venting of potentially harmful gasses or the safe release of excess pressure relies on functional valves. If they fail, overpressure situations can lead to equipment failures or personnel exposure to hazardous substances.

Increased Maintenance Costs

• Troubleshooting and Repairs: The cost of a replacement solenoid valve is often dwarfed by the associated labor time for diagnosis, system downtime, and potentially repairing damaged components caused by the initial failure.
• Lost Productivity: While production is down for repairs, you’re not just losing out on potential revenue—you’re still incurring operating expenses with no output to offset them. In some industries, a single hour of downtime can have a significant financial impact.
• The Value of Prevention: Proactive maintenance, including regular inspection and testing of solenoid valves, is a minor investment compared to the expenses incurred when failures lead to a chain reaction of problems.

Important: Context is key! A faulty valve in a low-pressure irrigation system is less concerning than a failing in a high-pressure hydraulic line on critical machinery. That’s why proper valve selection, understanding the risks in your specific application, and prioritizing preventative measures are crucial in mitigating these potential consequences.

Troubleshooting a Faulty Solenoid Valve

Meticulous troubleshooting is key for isolating a solenoid valve problem and differentiating between valve failure and other system issues. Before diving into replacements, follow these steps:

Visual Inspection

• External Checks: Carefully examine the valve body for cracks, leaks, or loose connections. Note any corrosion or signs of fluid ingress at the solenoid coil junction. Pay attention to mounting– a misaligned valve can experience excessive stress on its seals.
• Internal Examination (If Feasible): Disassembly can reveal fouling buildup, damaged seals, or a broken spring (depending on valve design). Caution: Refer to the datasheet for disassembly instructions, and be mindful of seals and small components. Never disassemble if the system is under pressure.
• Burn Marks: Discoloration of the solenoid coil could signal an overheated coil or electrical short circuit.

Electrical Checks

• Energize and Listen: With power off and safety precautions in place, manually actuate the valve if possible. Most valves have a slight audible click when energized. No sound could indicate a broken coil, open circuit, or incorrect voltage supply.
• Measure Voltage: Use a multimeter to ensure the solenoid receives the correct voltage at its terminals when activated. Voltage drops can be due to faulty wiring, a failing power supply, or undersized cables for the length of the run.
• Check Coil Resistance: With the coil disconnected from the circuit, use an ohmmeter to measure its resistance. Compare against the datasheet specification. A major deviation often indicates a damaged coil.

Fluid Pressure Testing

• Pressure Gauges: Install gauges before and after the valve to measure pressure when operational. Verify that the system has sufficient pressure (above the valve’s minimum operating pressure differential), and ensure the valve isn’t experiencing a back-pressure situation.
• Flow Restriction: Clogged lines, partially closed manual valves, or even a defective flow meter elsewhere in the system can mislead you into diagnosing a solenoid valve as the culprit. Systematically isolating sections helps identify the true source of the problem.

Important Extras

• Documentation Always Helps: The best troubleshooting begins with knowing the exact valve model its operating parameters, and having a complete system diagram at hand.
• Environmental Factors: Temperature extremes or high vibration can contribute to valve failures. Consider your operating environment, especially if the symptoms are intermittent.
• Fluid Compatibility: Aggressive fluids or contamination levels can exceed what the valve’s materials are designed to withstand. Internal damage can result, even if the external valve appears undamaged.

Remember, safety is always paramount when troubleshooting. Disconnect power, isolate the valve if necessary, and wear appropriate protective equipment when working with pressurized systems.

Preventing Solenoid Valve Failures

While solenoid valves are generally reliable components, avoiding failures requires careful upfront planning and an ongoing commitment to maintenance. Here’s how to minimize the risk of problems:

Proper Selection

• Valve Sizing vs. Pressure/Flow: Undersizing a valve leads to higher velocity flow and potentially damaging water hammer. Oversizing can result in sluggish operation or the inability to close fully. Partner with the valve manufacturer or a reputable supplier to size the valve correctly for your application.
• Material Compatibility: Aggressive chemicals, high temperatures, or abrasive particles in the fluid demand specialized valve body and seal materials. Always confirm the valve’s compatibility with the specific medium it will control.
• Electrical Type: Choose the correct voltage between AC or DC solenoids, and ensure your control system is compatible. Consider enclosure ratings (NEMA) for harsh wash-down or outdoor installations.

Regular Maintenance

• Inspection Schedule: Integrate visual checks of solenoid valves into your regular maintenance routines. Look for leaks, corrosion, or any signs of mechanical wear. Refer to the datasheet for recommended cleaning and seal replacement intervals.
• System-wide Cleanliness: Upstream filters and strainers protect your solenoid valves from debris that can cause clogging or premature seal wear. Maintaining these filters is often the most effective investment in prolonging valve life.
• Electrical Testing: Periodically checking coil resistance and verifying system power quality helps catch potential problems with the coil or its supply circuit before they lead to a complete failure.

Addressing Environmental Factors

• Extreme Temperatures: Excessive heat can accelerate the degradation of seals and coils. Use high-temperature rated valves, provide shielding, or consider cooling solutions in extreme environments. Conversely, freezing temperatures can cause fluids to solidify, jamming the valve or damaging seals.
• Vibration: Securely mount solenoid valves and use flexible piping connections if excessive vibration is a factor. Over time, vibration can loosen fittings and potentially damage internal valve components.
• Humidity and Moisture: If solenoid coils are not adequately sealed against moisture ingress, corrosion, and potential electrical faults can occur. Select valves with appropriate enclosure ratings (IP65 or higher) for harsh environments.

Proactive Investment Pays Off:

While proper selection and maintenance incur some costs, it pales compared to the potential losses from unplanned downtime, equipment damage, or safety incidents caused by a failed valve.

By taking preventative measures and understanding the operating environment, you can significantly extend the lifespan and reliability of your solenoid valves, safeguarding your process and avoiding costly failures.

Also Read: Comparing Longevity: 10-Year Lifetime Vs. 3-Year Lifetime In Battery Technology